← All stories
HardwarePlayStationXboxGrand Theft Auto VI

IGN's GTA 6 Comparison Flatters Xbox by Design

IGN pits the cheapest Xbox against the most expensive PlayStation and calls the result close. The framing deserves more scrutiny than the footage.

By Adam Voss

There is a particular kind of comparison video that tells you everything before a single frame of gameplay loads, and IGN's latest, matching the Xbox Series S against the PS5 Pro in Grand Theft Auto VI, is exactly that kind. You were, I assume, meant to read the premise as a fair fight. It is not one. It is the cheapest door into Leonida set against the most expensive, and the surprise the IGN description promises, that the two land closer than expected, says rather more about the question being asked than about either machine answering it.

Consider what is actually being measured. The PS5 Pro is Sony's premium proposition, the hardware equivalent of ordering off the tasting menu, while the Series S has spent its entire existence as the budget entry that Xbox insists will not hold the rest of the generation back. Put those two side by side and discover they are "closer than you'd think," and the honest headline is not that the Series S has overperformed; it is that the PS5 Pro, running the most technically ambitious release Rockstar has shipped, is being measured against a box a third its price and still being treated as the one that needs defending. That is not parity. That is grading on a curve so generous it practically apologizes for existing.

None of this is to pretend the Series S is worthless, nor that a budget console closing any gap at all is nothing; compact hardware doing competent work deserves the credit due it, briefly, before the conversation moves on. But the framing of the comparison, cheapest versus priciest and marvel that they're near, is the sort of trick a marketing department dreams up and a tech outlet repeats without asking who benefits from the premise. This site's own hands-on look, GTA 6 Xbox Review: Series X Shines, Series S Improvises, already used the word that matters here: improvises. A console that improvises is a console making do, not a console competing.

You may recall the promise, repeated at every Series S launch briefing, that the smaller box would never be the reason a game felt smaller. Grand Theft Auto VI, running on Rockstar's own engine at Rockstar's own ambitions, is precisely the title that promise was always going to meet its reckoning against, and no amount of favorable pairing in a comparison video changes which console was built to carry it and which was built to cope.